Debating Zinedine Zidane’s Legacy as a Player: Iconic Moments or Inconsistencies?

A Reddit user, lssie_hyoudou, recently stirred up a debate about Zinedine Zidane’s standing in the football world, with a claim that “Zidane ain’t even close to Platini.” This statement led to a discussion where fans shared their views on Zidane’s playing career.

Some fans concurred with the notion that Zidane, despite his Ballon d’Or and an impressive trophy collection, could be seen as a frustrating player. blackcatman even went so far as to assert that Michel Platini is the greatest French football player ever.

cuentanueva expressed frustration with the perception that Zidane is consistently ranked very high among all-time greats, particularly due to his successful tenure as a coach with Real Madrid.

The debate over Zidane’s playing career is indeed a lengthy one, as his brilliance on the field is often juxtaposed with questions about his consistency. Notably, in 2018, football writer Michael Cox suggested in a tweet that Zidane had only two good seasons in Italy and Spain.

However, fans counter these claims by highlighting Zidane’s ability to shine in crucial matches, despite any potential inconsistency. Still, some point out that there were instances when he struggled, especially when he became Juventus’ focal point during an injury-ridden season.

Zidane’s time at Real Madrid also had its share of ups and downs, including early difficulties in finding his ideal role on the pitch. Ultimately, Vicente del Bosque’s tactical solution helped both Zidane and the team.

In light of this ongoing debate, what’s your honest opinion on Zinedine Zidane as a player?