Xabi Alonso Chooses Between Mendy and Fran García – Decision Already Made if Neither Leaves

The left-back position has been a bit of a headache throughout the season. Both Ferland Mendy and Fran García have shown inconsistency, with Mendy’s case drawing more attention. Once the undisputed starter last season, Mendy’s performances have not met expectations for the current campaign.

With Xabi Alonso increasingly close to becoming Real Madrid’s next manager, the Basque coach has made up his mind. Between Mendy and Fran García, he’s chosen the former Rayo Vallecano player. Even if Fran hasn’t been spectacular, he’s the one who has shown the most promise throughout the season.

His youth and potential have also played a role in Xabi’s decision, as Fran still has room to grow over the next few seasons. This choice signals that, should Mendy remain at the club, he will no longer be the starting left-back.

Xabi Alonso’s decision

After making history with Bayer Leverkusen, Xabi Alonso has proven himself as a top-tier coach. His fresh ideas and tactical schemes that maximize the entire squad’s potential have naturally attracted Real Madrid’s interest. With Ancelotti’s departure imminent, Xabi appears to be the chosen successor.

His call on the left-back position shows that he’s already laying the groundwork for his Madrid project. Favoring Fran García over Mendy highlights Xabi’s lack of trust in the Frenchman, who has been unreliable all season.

Injuries and poor form—only 2,245 minutes played—have led Xabi to consider pushing Mendy out altogether. Meanwhile, Fran García, at just 25 years old, is seen as having much more potential.

Fran García beats Mendy

Despite being mostly benched last season, Fran has made solid progress this year. With 2,432 minutes played, his involvement is expected to increase further next season—potentially alongside a new reinforcement.